After all, Steve Herrell's Ice Cream began in Somerville, MA and Howard Johnson's in Quincy, MA. Each boasted a variety of flavors with one crucial difference: cost. As an undergraduate in Northampton, MA I often went to an equally good ice cream shop (now closed) nearer where I lived and less expensive than the Steve's branch. Later, I learned my friend, a Cape Codder, worshiped Ben & Jerry's for years, but when they sold their franchise, she elected to go to a favorite spot in Orleans, Ice Cream Cafe**.
With its pink and blue sign unobtrusively sitting outside the white clapboard house, you'd be hard-pressed to find the spot. Since, however, a rotary was built last year near Ice Cream Cafe, located on 5 South Orleans Road or Route 28, (the shop sits on Route 28 but the entrance, look for the awning with the same logo as the street sign, is on Cottage Street) the oasis is easier to locate and has more business than ever.
How does Ice Cream Cafe compete with so many other places, especially one shop on the way to Nauset Beach? Well, first and foremost, the owners don't nickle and dime. When you order a sundae, you get a genuine sundae and have a choice of multiple sizes. No extra costs--believe it or not--for nuts and generous amounts of homemade whip cream and hot fudge. Their equally scrumptious, homemade ice cream selections cover every allergy and/or taste preference: from gluten free (even g.f. sugar and wafer cones) to vegan, non-dairy or low-fat. Varieties include something for everyone: the gourmet (Chai), the adventurous (Chocolate Chili Pepper) to the earthy (Salty Caramel).
![]() |
Gluten free sugar cone with dairy free chocolate ice cream & chocolate sprinkles (Yelp/- Ice Cream Cafe -/Google Images) |
On a weeknight during the summer you'll see lines coming out the door as you would at most other places during weekends. If the reasons above aren't enough to explain my preference, then consider this: those other places squeeze every penny from locals and tourists alike while Ice Cream Cafe's prices are competitive but their portions generous. Their "Kiddie" size (one scoop) is a bargain.
Rare these days to find a place where you can order a cone served with a smile and watch song birds enter birdhouses hanging from abutting trees as you sit at your outdoor table feasting on a cool dessert, happy that you've picked the best summer ice cream shop in town and on Cape Cod.
*A special thank you to those who participated in my poll for topics this week.
**For the curious or the pedantics, the owners have elected not to use the accent aigu over the "e" in "Cafe."